More Pages: Austin Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52


DON'T WASTE YOUR TIME.

A lack of careful editorial supervision ruined this bookEven worse, the book's original edition contained substantial passages reprinted, largely intact and without attribution, from Bruce Cook's "Listen to the Blues," most notably those sections discussing Charley Patton and Robert Johnson. While I am not accusing Mr. Sonnier of willful plagiarism, it can be noted that at the time of his book's publication (1996), Mr. Cook's book had been out of print for many years. I caught this matter because Cook's book was republished at about the same time and I was reading the two of them simultaneously. When notified of this problem, Sonnier's publisher withdrew the book from distribution.
I do not know if there was a second edition which solved all these problems, but the first edition must be avoided at all costs. It is impossible to conceive of an audience for whom it would be both appropriate and adequate.


A disappointment

Very BadOne very unsettling aspect of Kliman's work is the way he ascribes sexual motives to the behavior of his young clients. He does not appear to sympathize with his clients and his work is an exercise in repetition. Another disturbing element of his work is the slap happy, overly permissive nursery he launched in 1965. Permissiveness often undermines authority and does not encourage responsibility. The sad part is that permissiveness does not speak to respect in general; the underlying message is one of having low expectations, therefore allow undesirable behavior to continue with impunity.
This is a complete waste and contributes nothing.


A TOTAL waste of timeNot that the other books in this series are any good either. They are all pretty burnt if you ask me. I guess it says something about me though that I have read a few of them. I guess I just don't know when to give up, or when to never start at all, sometimes.
In conclusion- stay away, far away.


Magic in name onlyIn addition to the uneveness of the eleven effects in the booklet -- most of which are not Magical and will be easily seen through unless the performer can be coached by a savvy teacher -- there are effects which are beyond the age range suggested, and the outcome will be frustration and disillusionment. If this is purchased for a complete beginner in Magic, it will end up in a junk pile; if purchased for someone with some experience in Magic, it will end up in a junk pile.
There are no real presentation points given in terms of patter or story lines, and, as anyone who has ever done any Magic knows (unless they have had a complete personality-ectomy) it is NOT the "trick" or the "fooling" that endears Magic to others, but the invitation to the audience (Mom and Dad to anyone else) to enjoy some mystery and fun. Sadly, all-too-many books for youngsters omit this concept, and the result is the perpetuation of the general view of "magicians" as losers. How much better even this poor excuse for a "Magic book" would have been had it provided some stories to seed some creativity.
I suspect that some parents will fall prey to impulse buying as this booklet and "kit" is attractively packaged (although mine was somewhat crushed in shipping) and feel that, at the low price, even if it becomes a "throw away" nothing is lost. They will be wrong. The right introduction to Magic is the most important aspect of the Art. No, I don't think that everyone who picks up a Magic book-- even a great Magic book -- will stay with Magic or even, sadly, show it the respect it (and wonderful Magicians) deserves, but why not try to maximize that possibility with books that provide what is needed and not just the impulse to buy? There are many great introductions to Magic, but this is not one of them.



